If Values Change Over Time: TOK Title 2 May 2027 Guide
By Michael Thompson · Education Specialist; 10 years teaching the IB at Bromsgrove School · Published 20 November 2026
"If values change over time, how can they, nevertheless, continue to guide the pursuit of knowledge? Discuss with reference to two areas of knowledge." For TOK Title 2 in the May 2027 session, answer in four moves: name the kind of value you mean, accept that it changes, show how it still steers inquiry in two areas of knowledge, then judge where that guidance holds and where it fails. The word 'nevertheless' already concedes the change, so an essay that argues values never really shift has answered a different question. The TOK essay is capped at 1,600 words, gets a single mark out of 10, and counts for two-thirds of your TOK grade. This guide covers the key terms, the best area-of-knowledge pairings, real examples you can check, and a section-by-section plan with word budgets. It is a scaffold, not a model essay, so every sentence you submit stays yours.
Key Takeaways
- Use the title exactly as published: Quote 'If values change over time, how can they, nevertheless, continue to guide the pursuit of knowledge? Discuss with reference to two areas of knowledge.' word for word, and check it against your school's official sheet.
- 'Nevertheless' concedes the change: Your job is to explain how values that do change can still guide inquiry, not to argue that they stay fixed.
- Pick one kind of value and stick to it: Ethical values (consent, fairness), epistemic values (accuracy, simplicity, reproducibility) and cultural values behave differently, so say which you mean and do not slide between them.
- You choose both areas of knowledge: Pick any two of history, the human sciences, the natural sciences, mathematics and the arts, and favour a pairing that gives a clear contrast.
- Kuhn puts values inside the paradigm: Kuhn later counted shared values as part of his 'disciplinary matrix', which Ernst Mayr sums up as 'a system of beliefs, values, and symbolic generalizations'. That makes paradigm shifts directly relevant to this title.
- Finish a full draft before the one comment: Your teacher can give written comments on one draft only, so hand in a complete argument with both areas of knowledge and a conclusion, not an outline.
In This Article
- What 'If Values Change Over Time, How Can They, Nevertheless, Continue to Guide the Pursuit of Knowledge' Asks
- Key Terms, Moral Relativism Examples and the Knowledge Questions
- Choosing Your Two Areas of Knowledge: Which Pairings Contrast Best
- Natural Sciences: Paradigm Shifts, Kuhn and Changing Epistemic Values
- Human Sciences, History, Mathematics and the Arts: Ethical Issues in Scientific Research and Beyond
- A 1,600-Word Essay Plan for TOK Title 2
- Common Traps on This Title and How to Use Your One Draft
- What to Do Next on Your Values Essay
1. What 'If Values Change Over Time, How Can They, Nevertheless, Continue to Guide the Pursuit of Knowledge' Asks
> "If values change over time, how can they, nevertheless, continue to guide the pursuit of knowledge? Discuss with reference to two areas of knowledge."
Students often search for this title as "if values change over time how can they continue to guide the pursuit of knowledge." That shorter version drops "nevertheless", the word that sets the direction of the whole essay. You must use the title exactly as published. Do not shorten it, paraphrase it, or merge it with a general question about values or science. An essay on a title that is not prescribed for its session scores zero, so check the wording and the title number (Title 2) against your school's official title sheet.
What it is really asking. This is a "how" question, not a "whether" question. The "if" clause and "nevertheless" already accept that values change, so your job is to explain how changing values can still guide inquiry, not to argue that they stay fixed. The instruction "Discuss" asks for a weighed answer across two areas of knowledge that you choose.
The assessment facts:
- You answer one of six prescribed titles that the IB issues for each examination session, and IB examiners mark the essay (IB TOK subject brief).
- The essay is no more than 1,600 words (IB Theory of Knowledge).
- An examiner gives it a single mark out of 10 on a global impression basis.
- It counts for two-thirds of your TOK grade and the exhibition counts for one-third (IB TOK subject brief).
- Your TOK grade (A to E) combines with your Extended Essay grade for up to 3 diploma points.
- Schools upload final essays to the IB by 15 March 2027 and set earlier internal deadlines. The IB's Theory of Knowledge page links to how it sets TOK deadlines.
Takeaway: before you read anything else, write a one-line restatement of what the question is asking in your own words. Use it as a private compass for planning. It does not replace the title.
2. Key Terms, Moral Relativism Examples and the Knowledge Questions
The readings below are this guide's interpretation, not IB wording. Choose one reading per term, state it in your introduction, and hold it for the whole essay.
"Values" can be read three ways, and your essay must say which kind it means:
- Ethical values: consent, fairness, avoiding harm.
- Epistemic values: accuracy, simplicity, reproducibility.
- Cultural values: what a society or community prizes.
Starting with reproducibility in the natural sciences and ending on consent in the human sciences, without saying so, is a slide between two different kinds of value. Name the switch if you make one.
| Term | Reading 1 | Reading 2 | Reading 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Change over time | Values are replaced | Values stay but are reinterpreted | Values are reweighted against each other |
| Guide | Sets the direction of inquiry | Sets limits on methods | Sets the standard for accepting a result |
| Pursuit of knowledge | The process of inquiry | The knowledge that inquiry produces | - |
The reweighting reading is often the most useful. It lets you argue that the list of values barely moves while their order does. That makes "nevertheless" easier to answer.
"Values change" is not the same as moral relativism, which is the view that no culture's or person's values are better than another's. A society that once accepted experiments on people who had not agreed to them, and now requires informed consent, has changed its values. Most people would say it changed them for better reasons. Moral relativism examples today usually look different: two communities hold opposite values, and neither can show the other is wrong. If your essay collapses into "anything goes", the title becomes unanswerable, because a value with no better or worse version cannot guide anything.
A key word such as "values" or "guide" can mean something slightly different in each area of knowledge. Find what those meanings share and use that as your definition. If an example will not fit your definition, ask whether the example or the definition is at fault: that tension can itself point to a knowledge question.
Knowledge questions written for this guide, for you to adapt:
- Can a standard that changes still count as a standard?
- Do changes in values improve inquiry or just redirect it?
- Is it the value or the reasons behind it that does the guiding?
- Who decides when a value has changed?
Takeaway: write one sentence for each term in the table above before you choose your examples.
3. Choosing Your Two Areas of Knowledge: Which Pairings Contrast Best
The current TOK course has five areas of knowledge: history, the human sciences, the natural sciences, mathematics and the arts. Title 2 leaves both choices to you. Titles 2 and 5 are the only May 2027 titles that do this, so on this title you have to build the contrast yourself.
| Pairing | What the contrast is | Why it works |
|---|---|---|
| Natural sciences + history | Epistemic values (reproducibility) against interpretive and cultural values about what is worth recording | One area tests claims by repeating them. The other cannot repeat the past at all. |
| Human sciences + natural sciences | Ethical limits on methods against epistemic standards for evidence | Strong ground for ethics in scientific research: consent can rule out a study that the evidence standards would otherwise demand. |
| Mathematics + the arts | Values that look stable (rigour, proof) against values that visibly shift (taste, what counts as art) | It tests whether some values really change at all. |
Comparing ethical constraints across areas of knowledge is a recognised TOK move. One specimen title in the IB's TOK subject brief asks: "Are there fewer ethical constraints on the pursuit of knowledge in the arts than in the human sciences?"
Avoid two kinds of pairing:
- Pairings that are too similar. If the same value does the same job in both areas, you write one argument twice.
- Pairings chosen for a favourite example. One good case does not make an area of knowledge the right choice for this title.
Takeaway: For each candidate pairing, write one sentence stating what the contrast would be. If you cannot write that sentence, drop the pairing.
4. Natural Sciences: Paradigm Shifts, Kuhn and Changing Epistemic Values
The natural sciences give you the clearest case that the framework guiding inquiry can change and still guide it. In The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962), Thomas Kuhn argued that science works inside a paradigm that guides the direction of inquiry and, in OUPblog's summary, "determines the standard of truth" (OUPblog). Long periods of "normal science" are broken by crisis and revolution, and then a new paradigm guides the next period.
Kuhn later called the most important sense of paradigm a "disciplinary matrix", which Ernst Mayr sums up as "a system of beliefs, values, and symbolic generalizations" (Mayr, Cambridge). This matters for Title 2 because values sit inside the structure that shifts. One caution: Mayr notes that one critic claimed Kuhn used "paradigm" in at least twenty different ways in his first edition. Define your term in one line before you use it.
Thomas Kuhn paradigm shift examples you can check:
| Case | Source | What it shows about the title |
|---|---|---|
| Classical to relativistic mechanics | OUPblog | The standard of what counts as a good explanation changed, but each framework still directed research |
| The Copernican Revolution, subject of Kuhn's 1957 book | OUPblog | A whole picture of the cosmos was replaced, not just one theory |
| The Darwinian revolution | Mayr | Mayr tests Kuhn on a concrete case, citing Darwin (1859) and Bowler's The Eclipse of Darwinism (1983) |
Counterclaim material. Janz and Nylin ask whether progress and the preservation of knowledge are possible at all if successive paradigms are incommensurable (Cambridge, 2026). If old and new standards cannot be compared, changing values might guide inquiry somewhere, but not clearly towards knowledge.
Response material. Two lines to test:
- Haixin Dang argues the main constraint on group belief revision is the weight of the evidence (Cambridge, 2024). Dang writes about beliefs, not values. Extending this to epistemic values is your own argument, so do not attribute it to Dang.
- Lakatos' "hard core" and "protective belt" (Janz and Nylin) suggest some commitments stay protected while others shift.
Takeaway: pick one case from the table, name which epistemic value changed in it, and say in a single sentence what still guided inquiry across the shift.
5. Human Sciences, History, Mathematics and the Arts: Ethical Issues in Scientific Research and Beyond
These four areas of knowledge supply the second half of most pairings. Every example below is real and widely documented, but confirm the details in a primary or scholarly source before you use them. "Values" may mean consent in one area and rigour in another, so name the kind you mean.
Human sciences
- Milgram's obedience experiments at Yale (from 1961) and the Stanford Prison Experiment (1971): both were permitted when they ran and are now widely judged unacceptable. The findings are still discussed, but the ethical standards that allowed them no longer apply.
- The US Public Health Service Tuskegee syphilis study (1932 to 1972) and the Belmont Report (1979): outrage over the study led to formal principles, including informed consent, that now guide how human-subject research is designed. This is your strongest "how" example, because the changed value directly shapes method.
- Henrietta Lacks and the HeLa cell line (1951): consent norms changed after the knowledge already existed. That raises a harder question: does knowledge produced under older values carry their flaws?
- AI ethics in scientific research: questions such as consent for training data show norms still forming. Treat this as values in motion and avoid specific policy claims.
History
- *Herbert Butterfield's critique of "Whig" history (The Whig Interpretation of History, 1931):* this rejected judging the past as a march towards the present, while keeping the commitment to evidence.
- *E. H. Carr's What Is History? (1961):* Carr argues that the historian's own standpoint shapes which facts become historical facts.
- *E. P. Thompson's The Making of the English Working Class (1963):* "history from below" redirected the questions historians ask towards ordinary people. The commitment to archival evidence did not change.
- Debates over public statues, such as the toppling of Edward Colston's statue in Bristol in 2020: groups now disagree about whose past deserves honour. These are often given as ethical relativism examples in real life, but disagreement alone does not show that no view is better than another.
Mathematics
- Non-Euclidean geometry (Lobachevsky 1829, Bolyai 1832, Riemann 1854): mathematicians stopped valuing axioms as self-evident truths, yet rigour still guided the work.
- The Appel-Haken proof of the four-colour theorem (1976): this computer-assisted proof prompted debate over whether a proof must be checkable by hand.
- Thomas Hales and Samuel Ferguson's proof of the Kepler conjecture (announced 1998): referees could not check all of its computer calculations, so Hales led the Flyspeck project, which completed a formal, computer-verified proof in 2014. The value placed on certainty held, while what counted as checking a proof changed.
The arts
- The Paris Salon and the Salon des Refusés (1863): painters such as Manet, and later the Impressionists, had work rejected by the official Salon before being canonised. The standards of judgement moved, but judgement itself continued.
- *Marcel Duchamp's Fountain (1917):* the value placed on craft gave way to the value placed on the idea.
One distinction to keep: moral relativism examples today, such as the statue debates, show people disagreeing at the same moment. The title is about values changing over time. If you use both, label which one you are discussing. Otherwise your argument will drift away from the question the title actually asks.
6. A 1,600-Word Essay Plan for TOK Title 2
The table below is a scaffold written for this guide, not a model essay. It gives you the shape and the word budget. The ideas and examples have to be yours. The TOK essay is capped at 1,600 words (IB), so every section below has a fixed allowance.
| Section | What it does | Example slot | Word budget |
|---|---|---|---|
| Introduction | Quotes the title exactly: "If values change over time, how can they, nevertheless, continue to guide the pursuit of knowledge? Discuss with reference to two areas of knowledge." Defines the key terms, states the knowledge question, and sets out the line the essay will take | [your definition of "values": ethical, epistemic or cultural] | 150 |
| AOK 1: claim | Shows how changing values still guide inquiry in this area | [your example] | 250 |
| AOK 1: counterclaim | Tests the claim against a case where changing values misled or stalled inquiry | [your example] | 200 |
| AOK 2: claim | Same job, second area | [your example] | 250 |
| AOK 2: counterclaim | Same job, second area | [your example] | 200 |
| Comparison | Shows where changing values guide inquiry in the same way in both areas, and where they differ | [your point of contrast] | 300 |
| Conclusion | Gives a judged answer and its implications | [your judgement] | 250 |
| Total | 1,600 |
The 1,600 words is a maximum, not a target to pad. As a planning suggestion from this guide, around four well-developed examples, one per claim and counterclaim, usually fit better than a long list.
There is one trap in this plan to watch for. Because "nevertheless" concedes that values change, your counterclaims should not argue that values stay fixed. They should test whether changing values can still guide inquiry, for example where a shift in values arrived too late to prevent harm. Fix which kind of value you mean in the introduction, and keep using that kind of value in all four example slots.
7. Common Traps on This Title and How to Use Your One Draft
Each trap below has a straightforward fix.
| Trap | Fix |
|---|---|
| Denying that values change | "Nevertheless" concedes the change. Argue how changing values still guide inquiry, not whether they change. |
| Sliding between ethical, epistemic and cultural values | Say in your introduction which kind you mean. Flag it explicitly if you switch. |
| Collapsing into "it's all relative" | Moral relativism examples can open a counterclaim. Your conclusion still needs a judgement about how guidance survives change. |
| Retelling Kuhn as a book summary | Pick one specific paradigm shift and say which values changed and which stayed. |
| Writing two parallel mini-essays | Write a section that compares the two areas of knowledge directly. |
| Altering or shortening the title | Quote it exactly: "If values change over time, how can they, nevertheless, continue to guide the pursuit of knowledge? Discuss with reference to two areas of knowledge." |
Two quieter traps also cost clarity:
- Using familiar examples without saying what they show about values. A famous case does no work until you name the value involved.
- Misattributing claims to sources. A source about changing beliefs is not automatically about changing values. Cite only what a source actually says.
Getting the most from your single draft
Your teacher can give written comments on one draft only. Conversations about the essay are recorded on a planning and progress form, which is sent to the IB with your essay.
Comments are most useful on a complete argument, not an outline. Have these finished before you hand the draft in:
- the exact title
- your definitions
- your knowledge question
- both areas of knowledge, each with a claim and a counterclaim
- the comparison section
- a conclusion with a judgement
- a length within or close to 1,600 words
- a list of sources
Takeaway: before you submit the draft, write down two questions you want your teacher's comments to answer.
8. What to Do Next on Your Values Essay
Your first job is a date. The IB upload deadline is 15 March 2027, but your school will set an earlier internal deadline for the one draft your teacher can comment on in writing. Find out that internal date this week and write it in your planner.
Then do three quick jobs:
- Confirm the wording. Check the title number and exact wording against your school's official sheet, not a copy from elsewhere.
- Pick your values. Decide whether you mean ethical, epistemic or cultural values, and write that choice down in one line.
- Shortlist two areas of knowledge. For each, find one real example and check its date and details.
Book a short conversation with your TOK teacher once those three are done, because it will be recorded on your planning and progress form. Bring your shortlist, not a finished draft.
FAQ
Which two areas of knowledge work best for TOK Title 2 in May 2027?
You choose both from history, the human sciences, the natural sciences, mathematics and the arts. Pairings with a clear contrast, such as natural sciences with history or mathematics with the arts, make the comparison section easier to write.
Can I use Kuhn's paradigm shifts for the values change over time title?
Yes, it connects directly, because Kuhn later counted shared values as part of the 'disciplinary matrix' behind a paradigm (Ernst Mayr sums it up as 'a system of beliefs, values, and symbolic generalizations'), but tie it to a specific case rather than summarising his book.
How many examples fit in a 1,600-word TOK essay?
The essay is capped at 1,600 words, so this guide's plan uses one developed example per claim and counterclaim. That gives roughly four examples across two areas of knowledge.
Can I shorten or reword the TOK Title 2 question?
No. The prescribed title must be used exactly as published, so quote it word for word and check it against your school's official title sheet.
Does the title want me to argue that values do not really change?
No. 'Nevertheless' concedes that values change, so the essay must explain how changing values can still guide inquiry rather than deny the change.
When is the May 2027 TOK essay deadline?
Schools upload final essays to the IB by 15 March 2027, and each school sets an earlier internal deadline, including one for the single draft your teacher comments on.
References
- Diploma Programme Subject Brief - Theory of knowledge, first assessment 2022 (International Baccalaureate Organization) - https://www.ibo.org/globalassets/new-structure/programmes/dp/pdfs/tok-sb-english.pdf
- Theory of knowledge - International Baccalaureate - https://www.ibo.org/programmes/diploma-programme/curriculum/dp-core/theory-of-knowledge/
- Thomas Kuhn and the paradigm shift - Philosopher of the Month | OUPblog - https://blog.oup.com/2019/11/thomas-kuhn-paradigm-shift-philosopher-of-the-month
- Do Thomas Kuhn's scientific revolutions take place? (Chapter 9) - What Makes Biology Unique? - https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/what-makes-biology-unique/do-thomas-kuhns-scientific-revolutions-take-place/AE03812B3ACCB549352A42491F58289A
- Paradigm-Driven Science (Chapter 5) - Understanding Science - https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/understanding-science/paradigmdriven-science/2283F4F3D3B9118EFBD0FCD3F13B3FC8
- Paradigm Shifts and Group Belief Change (Chapter 8) - Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions at 60 - https://www.cambridge.org/core/books/kuhns-the-structure-of-scientific-revolutions-at-60/paradigm-shifts-and-group-belief-change/E71FD49EA06FBEB797D030581373A37B